The case of O’Sullivan v Trading 212 UK Limited” (2026) EWCC 32 deals with the issue of departure from an approved costs budget. This was a case where the parties ran up significant legal costs on a claim where monetary relief was sought as pleaded at £37,106. The court found that the claim was worth only a few thousand pounds and that the parties has spent around 100 times more on legal fees than the claim was actually worth.

The court held that there was a good reason to depart from the approved budget under CPR 3.18. It was stated that “the Judge who made the costs management order did so on a basis that has turned out to be completely wrong. Had the Judge known what I know now, it is vanishingly unlikely that this case would have been allocated to the multi-track and it is all but inconceivable that the parties would have been allotted 3.5 days of court time for the trial.”

 The hourly rates were held to be excessive in that London 1 solicitors were not required for a claim which started in Hull. The hourly rates were reduced with the same reduction applied to the budgeted phases. It was held that the level of expenditure was disproportionately high.

This case is a reminder that the budget can be revised downwards where the budget has been set in circumstances which have changed drastically. A party, when drafting their budget, cannot assume that the budget figure will not be revised retrospectively.