Those of us with long memories may recall the onerous duties placed upon solicitors under the now repealed Conditional Fee Agreement Regulations 2000. Failing to investigate alternative methods of funding lead to the CFA being held to be invalid with no costs recoverable under the same.
The Case of Evans v Fletchers Solicitors Ltd (2026) EWHC 1523 (SCCO) return to this issue. This was a Solicitor/Client Assessment under section 70 of the Solicitors act 1974. The case arose as a result of a road traffic accident where the Claimant was riding a motorcycle. The claim settled in the sum of £250,000.00. The Defendant sent an invoice to the Claimant including a success fee of £30,365.13 capped at 25% of the relevant damages.
The Claimant requested an assessment of the bill and the key issue was whether or not the case could have been funded by way of legal expenses insurance. As part of the sign up to the CFA, the Claimant, via his wife, completed a funding options form confirming that the family held legal expense insurance on their home insurance policy with Zurich. The Solicitor contacted Zurich who subsequently provided a policy booklet with information regarding legal expenses. The fee earner took he view that they had been unable to establish that the BTE policy was in place to provide cover to the Claimant. The Claimant’s new solicitor made enquiries and established the position with little difficulty.
The court held that the Defendant’s enquiries were unreasonable and referred to the cases of Sawar v Alam (2001) EWCA Civ 1401 where the Court of Appeal held that the solicitor should invite the client to bring any relevant insurance policies to the first interview. Reference was also made to Garrett v Halton Borough Council (2006) EWCA Civ 1017 where guidance was given to Solicitors to make enquiries of potential BTE insurers even where the client is unsure as to whether any such cover was available.
The Judge concluded that “making desultory enquiries with Zurich and without getting to the LEI company at all cannot be said to be making any form of reasonable enquiry”. He also stated “the correspondence, in my view, is drafted in a way which sought to encourage a lacklustre response from any potential LEI insurer so that the existing CFA arrangement was not disturbed by any putative BTE cover “. The Judge went on to disallow the success fee in its entirety as the success fee would not have been incurred if the BTE policy had been correctly utilised.
The consequences of the above is that the duty to undertake BTE investigations survives the Jackson Reforms and this is very much part of any subsequent Solicitors Act assessment.
