The recent case of Spicer v Greene King Brewing and Retailing Ltd (2026) EWCC 18 concerned the issue of deduction of additional liabilities, including success fees and After the Event insurance premiums in personal injury claims brought on behalf of children.

The case concerned a Claimant who was then aged 4 and visited a Public House with his family. Whilst playing in the garden the Claimant slipped on uneven paving slabs and suffered a nasty gash to his forehead. He was taken to hospital where the wound was stitched and he was discharged. He was left with a faint scar below the hairline. It was stated that this was a straightforward occupier’s liability personal injury claim which could be settled promptly once the relevant medical evidence was obtained. Special damages were minimal. The solicitors advised the Claimant’s mother to sign up to a CFA and take out ATE insurance. The medical expert instructed was through their wholly owned subsidiary medical agency, On Time Reports Limited”. A straight forward medical report was produced. An offer was accepted in the sum of £10,000.00. Part 8 proceedings were issued.

At the Infant approval Hearing the proposed settlement of £10,000.00 was approved. Between the parties fixed costs had been agreed including all disbursements. The only further issue to consider was the request for deduction of the success fee under the CFA and of the ATE premium set at 10% of the recovered damages plus IPT.

A schedule of solicitor and own client costs was produced in the sum of £13,316.00 worth of profit costs with 73.1 hours claimed by 18 different fee earners. The CFA assessed the percentage of success fee at a maximum of 100%. As 100% of £13,316.00 would be greater than 25% of damages, a success fee of £2,500.00 was sought together with an ATE premium of £1120.00. Therefore, the total deduction was £3620.00 which equated to 36.2% of the damages.

District Judge Lumb was sceptical as to the level of incurred costs and directed the solicitors to file the full file of papers for inspection and assessment. DJ Lumb stated that when the litigation friend was spoken to at the hearing it was clear she did not really understand what was in the witness statement filed on her behalf or it’s meaning and effect and that she had been conditioned to expect 25% of the damaged would be deducted for the success fee as the norm. It was also stated that the witness statement prepared in relation to the ATE insurance policy was more of a note of the relevant parts of the CPR. This was not prepared in the interests of the client but more in the interests of the solicitor in seeking to persuade the court to allow the ATE premium and success fee to be deducted from damages and paid to them.

The Solicitors Code of Conduct was considered together with a Warning Notice issued by the SRA in January 2026 regarding “no win no fee” agreements. The Warning Notice set out concerns that some fee arrangements were not meeting the standards expected under the SRA principles and the Code of Conduct and in particular a concern that clients’ interests were being compromised by firms structuring “no win no fee” agreements in ways that serve their own commercial interests other than acting in their clients’ best interests.

The contractual hourly rates under the CFA were significantly higher than the guideline hourly rate issued by the SCCO. Although the retainer documentation mentioned the hourly rate charges were higher than other firms may charge, they sought to justify this by their expertise in these matters. The repeated reference to limitation of the client’s liability for costs being limited to 25% of damages was clearly designed to down play any importance of the hourly rates in the CFA from the client’s perspective as the result would always be the same, in that they would expect a reduction of 25% of damages and the deduction of the ATE premium.

It was held that base costs should be no more than £3000.00 and the 100% success fee could not be justified given the minimal risks involved in the case being unsuccessful. The success fee was reduced to 11%. It was also stated it was unreasonable for the ATE premium to be taken out as there was no risk to insure against. The only real risk was the failure to beat a part 36 offer but given approval by the court was always going to be required that risk was practically non-existent.

In conclusion the appropriate deduction of additional liabilities from the Claimant’s damages was limited to the success fee £330.00 plus vat

It is clear that it is necessary for solicitors to review their business models and it appears that the SRA could investigate given the content of the Warning Notice of January 2026.